鱼菜共生系统中种养密度和投喂频率对大口黑鲈生长及水质的影响

doi:10.13304/j.nykjdb.2025.0203

中国农业科技导报 ›› 2025, Vol. 27 ›› Issue (11): 43-55.DOI: 10.13304/j.nykjdb.2025.0203

鱼菜共生系统中种养密度和投喂频率对大口黑鲈生长及水质的影响

王岚¹(), 史东杰²(), 朱建亚², 张晋京², 张悦³(), 黄杰²(), 谢吉国³, 吴尚²

^1.北京市房山区农业环境和生产监测站，北京 101100
^2.北京市农林科学院，农业农村部华北都市农业重点实验室，国家淡水渔业工程技术研究中心（北京），北京 100068
^3.北京市大兴区畜牧水产技术推广站，北京 102699

收稿日期:2025-03-20 接受日期:2025-08-01 出版日期:2025-11-15 发布日期:2025-11-17
通讯作者: 张悦,黄杰
作者简介:王岚 E-mail：735677065@qq.com
史东杰E-mail：sdj19850104@163.com第一联系人：王岚和史东杰为共同第一作者。
基金资助:
国家淡水渔业工程技术研究中心（北京）专项经费项目(PT2025-19);北京市农业农村局农产品质量安全项目(11000024T000002865825);北京市农林科学院科技创新能力建设专项(KJCX20230814);北京市科学技术委员会科技助力乡村振兴项目(BJKWXUNZX24);北京市大兴区渔耕一体模式系统升级改造项目(11011524T000002695941)

Effect of Aquapnics Cultrue Mode on Growth of Micropterus salmoides and Water Quality

Lan WAGN¹(), Dongjie SHI²(), Jianya ZHU², Jinjing ZHANG², Yue ZHANG³(), Jie HUANG²(), Jiguo XIE³, Shang WU²

^1.Beijing Fangshan District Agriculture Environment and Production Monitoring Office，Beijing 101100，China
^2.Key Laboratory of Urban Agriculture （North China），Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs，National Engineering Research Center for Freshwaters （Beijing），Beijing Academy of Agriculture and Forestry Sciences，Beijing 100068，China
^3.Beijing Daxing District Livestock and Aquaculture Technology Promotion Station，Beijing 102699，China

Received:2025-03-20 Accepted:2025-08-01 Online:2025-11-15 Published:2025-11-17
Contact: Yue ZHANG,Jie HUANG

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

为研究不同种植密度、养殖密度和投喂频率对鱼菜共生系统中大口黑鲈生长、肌肉营养成分及水质的影响，设置生菜种植密度分别为32（a₁）、46（a₂）、60株·m^-2（a₃），大口黑鲈养殖密度分别为8（b₁）、13（b₂）、18kg·m^-3（b₃），投喂频率为1（c₁）、2（c₂）、3次·d^-1（c₃），通过3因素3水平的组合处理筛选种养密度及投喂频率的最优组合。结果表明，种植密度对增重量、增重率、特定生长率和饲料系数均影响显著；投喂频率对增重量影响显著；投喂频率对肌肉中粗蛋白、粗脂肪含量影响显著。各处理的氨氮、亚硝酸盐氮、总氮和总磷含量均显著升高，第7天时达到高峰；氨氮、亚硝酸盐氮、总氮在第37天以后呈稳定状态，总磷在第25天以后呈稳定状态，a₂b₁c₂和a₂b₂c₃处理的水质指标较优。在此鱼菜共生系统中，生菜的种植密度为46株·m^-2、大口黑鲈养殖密度为13 kg·m^-3、投喂频率为3 次·d^-1时，大口黑鲈生长和肌肉品质较好，且具有较好的水质调控作用。研究结果为鱼菜共生系统的种养管理提供理论参考。

关键词: 鱼菜共生, 种养密度, 投喂频率, 生长, 肌肉, 水质

Abstract:

To explore the impact of different planting densities， stocking densities and feeding frequencies on performance of Micropterus salmoides and water quality in fish-vegetable symbiosis，the plant densities were set at 32 （a₁），46 （a₂），60 plants·m^-2（a₃）， the stocking densities were set at 8 （b₁），13 （b₂），18 kg·m^-3 （b₃）， the feeding frequency were set at 1 （c₁），2（c₂），3 times·d^-1 （c₃），respectively. The optimal combination of stocking density and feeding frequency were screened through the combined treatment of 3 factors and 3 levels. The results showed that planting density had significant effect on weight gain， weight gain rate， specific growth rate and feed coefficient； feeding frequency had significant effect on weight gain， feeding frequency had significant effect on the crude protein and crude fat content in muscle. The contents of ammonia nitrogen， nitrite nitrogen， total nitrogen and total phosphorus in each treatment group increased significantly over time， peaking on the 7^th day. The ammonia nitrogen， nitrite nitrogen and total nitrogen were stable after 37 d， while the total phosphorus stabilized after 25 d. The water quality indexes of a₂b₁c₂ and a₂b₂c₃ treatments were better than those of the other treatments. In this aquaponics system， the lettuce planting density of 6 plants·m^-2， the largemouth bass stocking density of 13 kg·m^-3 and the feeding frequency of 3 times·d^-1 could yield the optimal performance in terms of growth and muscle quality of largemouth bass， and water quality regulation effect. Above results provided a theoretical reference for the planting and stocking in aquaponics system.

Key words: fish vegetable symbiosis, planting density, feeding frequency, growth, muscle, water quality

中图分类号:

S964

王岚, 史东杰, 朱建亚, 张晋京, 张悦, 黄杰, 谢吉国, 吴尚. 鱼菜共生系统中种养密度和投喂频率对大口黑鲈生长及水质的影响[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2025, 27(11): 43-55.

Lan WAGN, Dongjie SHI, Jianya ZHU, Jinjing ZHANG, Yue ZHANG, Jie HUANG, Jiguo XIE, Shang WU. Effect of Aquapnics Cultrue Mode on Growth of Micropterus salmoides and Water Quality[J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2025, 27(11): 43-55.

图/表 12

参考文献 31

[1]	MAKHDOM S, SHEKARABI S P H, SHAMSAIE MEHRGAN M. Biological nutrient recovery from culturing of pearl gourami (Trichogaster leerii) by cherry tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) in aquaponic system [J]. Environ. Sci. Pollut. Res. Int., 2017, 24(25): 20634-20640.
[2]	MULOKOZI D P, BERG H, TAMATAMAH R A, et al.. Integration of Nile Tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) and vegetables (Amaranthus hybridus and Brassica rapa pekinensis) for improved production,water use efficiency and nutrient recycling [J]. Aquac. Fish Fish., 2022, 2(6): 493-506.
[3]	史东杰, 胡金有, 王赛赛, 等. 鱼菜共生养殖模式对锦鲤生长、消化酶活力的影响及养殖推广效益测算[J]. 河南农业科学, 2019, 48(10): 155-161.
	SHI D J, HU J Y, WANG S S, et al.. Effects of aquaponics mode on growth,digestive enzyme activity and promotion benefit of Cyprinus carpio haematopterus [J]. J. Henan Agric. Sci., 2019, 48(10): 155-161.
[4]	李云赫. 安康地区鱼菜共生养殖模式中蔬菜及鱼类种类和密度的初步研究[D]. 杨凌: 西北农林科技大学, 2024.
	LI Y H. A preliminary study on the species and density of vegetables and fish in aquaponics culture model in Ankang area [D]. Yangling: Northwest A&F University, 2024.
[5]	刘爽, 安诗琦, 严子微, 等. 现代鱼菜共生技术研究进展与展望[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2020, 22(3): 160-166.
	LIU S, AN S Q, YAN Z W, et al.. Progress and prospect of aquaponics technology [J]. J. Agric. Sci. Technol., 2020, 22(3): 160-166.
[6]	刘星, 王继涛, 虎治军, 等. 鱼菜共生系统下种养密度和投喂频率对鲫鱼生长及品质的影响[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2022, 24(1): 192-201.
	LIU X, WANG J T, HU Z J, et al.. Effects of planting density and feeding frequency on growth and quality of Crucian carp under aquaponics system [J]. J. Agric. Sci. Technol.,2022, 24(1): 192-201.
[7]	LIANG J Y, CHIEN Y H. Effects of feeding frequency and photoperiod on water quality and crop production in a Tilapia-water spinach raft aquaponics system [J]. Int. Biodeterior. Biodegrad., 2013, 85: 693-700.
[8]	PETREA S M, CRISTEA V, DEDIU L, et al.. A study of nitrogen dynamics in an integrated stellate sturgeon and spinach aquaponic system with different crop densities [J]. Bull. Univ. Agric. Sci. Vet. Med. Anim.Sci.Biotechnol., 2014,71(2): 219-225.
[9]	YU P F, CHEN H, LIU M L, et al.. Current status and application of largemouth bass (Micropterus salmoides) germplasm resources [J]. Reprod. Breed., 2024, 4(2): 73-82.
[10]	LATIMER D G W. Official Methods of Analysis of AOAC International [M]. Oxford:Oxford University Press, 2023.
[11]	国家环境保护总局《水和废水监测分析方法》编委会.水和废水监测分析方法[M].第4版.北京:中国环境科学出版社,2002: 243-284.
[12]	倪金金, 王裕玉, 徐钢春, 等. 养殖密度对池塘循环水养殖大口黑鲈生长、生理指标和GH、IGF-I基因表达的影响[J]. 大连海洋大学学报, 2020, 35(6): 805-813.
	NI J J, WANG Y Y, XU G C, et al.. Effects of stocking density on growth,physiological indices and expression of GH and IGF-I genes of largemouth bass Micropterus salmoides in in-pond raceway culture systems [J].J. Dalian Ocean. Univ., 2020, 35(6): 805-813.
[13]	IRWIN S, O’HALLORAN J, FITZGERALD R D. Stocking density,growth and growth variation in juvenile turbot,Scophthalmus maximus (Rafinesque) [J]. Aquaculture, 1999, 178(1): 77-88.
[14]	莫介化, 李春枝, 王晓斌, 等. 不同养殖密度大口黑鲈在室内工厂化循环水养殖系统中的生长特性[J]. 淡水渔业, 2022, 52(3): 98-104.
	MO J H, LI C Z, WANG X B, et al.. The growth characteristics of Micropterus salmoides with different stocking densities in indoor recirculating aquaculture system (RAS) [J].Freshw. Fish., 2022, 52(3): 98-104.
[15]	秦峰, 陈建明, 张海琪, 等. 投喂频率对驯化摄食配合饲料后大口黑鲈鱼苗生长性能和肠道菌群的影响[J]. 饲料研究, 2024, 47(18): 58-62.
	QIN F, CHAN J M, ZHANG H Q, et al.. Effects of feeding frequency on growth performance and gut microbiota of large-mouth bass fry after acclimation with compound feed [J]. Feed Res., 2024, 47(18): 58-62.
[16]	孙洪庆, 王洋, 杨广, 等. 投喂频率对大口黑鲈幼鱼生长及消化的影响[J]. 饲料工业, 2023, 44(20): 58-65.
	SUN H Q, WANG Y, YANG G, et al.. Effect of feeding frequency on growth and digestion of Micropterus salmoides [J].Feed. Ind., 2023, 44(20): 58-65.
[17]	平洪领, 付铁中, 张涛, 等. 投喂频率对横带髭鲷(Hapalogenys mucronatus)幼鱼生长、体成分、消化系统酶活及组织结构的影响[J]. 海洋与湖沼, 2024, 55(6): 1550-1558.
	PING H L, FU T Z, ZHANG T, et al.. Effects of feeding frequency on growth,body composition,digestive system enzyme activity,and tissue structure of juvenile Hapalogenys mucronatus [J]. Oceanol. Limnol. Sin., 2024, 55(6): 1550-1558.
[18]	ADINEH H, NADERI M, KHADEMI HAMIDI M, et al.. Biofloc technology improves growth,innate immune responses,oxidative status,and resistance to acute stress in common carp (Cyprinus carpio) under high stocking density [J]. Fish Shellfish Immunol., 2019, 95: 440-448.
[19]	AMADOU L Y M, FAROKH N, ROBANE F, et al.. Feeding frequency effect on growth,body composition,feed utilization and ammonia excretion of juvenile grouper Epinephelus coioides [J]. Int. J. Fish. Aquat. Stud., 2019, 7(1): 116-121.
[20]	杨育凯, 黄小林, 林黑着, 等. 黄斑篮子鱼幼鱼适宜投喂频率的研究[J]. 动物营养学报, 2020, 32(4): 1809-1816.
	YANG Y K, HUANG X L, LIN H Z, et al.. Optimal feeding frequency for juvenile Siganus oramin [J]. Chin. J. Anim. Nutr., 2020, 32(4): 1809-1816.
[21]	谢苏明, 徐钢春, 王裕玉, 等. 投喂频率对池塘循环水养殖大口黑鲈消化酶、组织结构及脂代谢酶基因表达的影响[J]. 中国水产科学, 2021, 28 (2): 157-166.
	XIE S M, XU G C, WANG Y Y, et al.. Effects of feeding frequency on digestive enzymes, histomorphology, and gene expression of lipid metabolic enzymes of largemouth bass (Micropterus salmoides) reared in in-pond raceway culture systems [J]. J. Fish. Sci. China, 2021, 28 (2): 157-166.
[22]	王伟, 张凯强, 温海深, 等. 投喂频率对花鲈幼鱼胃排空、生长性能和体组分的影响[J]. 中国海洋大学学报(自然科学版), 2018, 48(6): 55-62.
	WANG W, ZHANG K Q, WEN H S, et al.. Effects of feeding frequency on gastric evacuation,growth performance and body composition of juvenile Lateolabrax maculatus [J].Period. Ocean. Univ. China, 2018, 48(6): 55-62.
[23]	胥晴, 原居林, 倪蒙, 等. 不同净养时间和养殖密度下大口黑鲈的表型特征、健康状况及肌肉营养品质的比较[J]. 水产学报, 2025, 49(1): 176-192.
	XU Q, YUAN J L, NI M, et al.. Comparative study on phenotypic characteristics, health status and muscle nutritional quality of largemouth bass (Micropterus salmoides) under different depuration time and stocking density [J]. J. Fisheries China, 2025, 49(1): 176-192.
[24]	PICCOLO G, MARONO S, BOVERA F, et al.. Effect of stocking density and protein/fat ratio of the diet on the growth of dover sole (Solea solea) [J]. Aquac. Res., 2008, 39(16): 1697-1704.
[25]	SOMERVILLE C, COHEN M, PANTANELLA E, et al.. Small-scale aquaponic food production-integrated fish and plant farming [M]. Rome: FAO,United Nations, 2014: 21-34.
[26]	WONGKIEW S, HU Z, CHANDRAN K, et al.. Nitrogen transformations in aquaponic systems:a review [J]. Aquac. Eng., 2017, 76: 9-19.
[27]	WANG C, XU S J, JIANG C C, et al.. Improvement of the growth performance,intestinal health,and water quality in juvenile crucian carp (Carassius auratus Gibelio) biofortified system with the bacteria-microalgae association [J/OL]. Aquaculture, 2023, 562: 738848 [2025-02-26]..
[28]	罗小龙, RAUAN Abdessan, 邢君霞, 等. 循环水系统结合鱼菜、紫外处理对镜鲤生长及水质的影响 [J]. 淡水渔业, 2020, 50(2): 18-25.
	LUO X L, RAUAN A, XING J X, et al.. Effects of growing lettuce and using UV lamp on the growth of Cyprinuscarpio var.specularis and water quality in a recirculating aquaculture system [J]. Freshw. Fish., 2020, 50(2): 18-25.
[29]	蔡淑芳, 陈永快, 陈敏, 等. 鱼菜共生系统中植物密度对水质及鱼菜生长的影响[J]. 渔业现代化, 2018, 45(5): 19-25.
	CAI S F, CHEN Y K, CHEN M, et al.. Effects of plant density on water quality and growth of fish and vegetables in aquaponics system [J]. Fish. Mod., 2018, 45(5): 19-25.
[30]	葛滢, 常杰, 王晓月, 等. 两种程度富营养化水中不同植物生理生态特性与净化能力的关系[J]. 生态学报, 2000, 20(6): 1050-1055.
	GE Y, CHANG J, WANG X Y, et al.. Relationship between the physiological characters and purification ability of different plants in waters with two trophic levels [J]. Acta Ecol. Sin., 2000, 20(6): 1050-1055.
[31]	KRISHAN GARG S. Effects of feeding frequency on growth performance,digestibility and nutrient retention in fingerlings of Indian major carps-effect on nitrogen retention and excretion of metabolites [J]. Biol. Sci., 2017, 1(1): 39-61.

组别 Group	处理组合 Treatment combination	a：种植密度 Planting density/（kg·m^-3）	b：养殖密度 Breeding density/（kg·m^-3）	c：投喂频率/（次·d^-1） Feeding frequency/（times·d^-1）
M1	a₁b₁c₁	32	8	1
M2	a₁b₂c₂	32	13	2
M3	a₁b₃c₃	32	18	3
M4	a₂b₁c₂	46	8	2
M5	a₂b₂c₃	46	13	3
M6	a₂b₃c₁	46	18	1
M7	a₃b₁c₃	60	8	3
M8	a₃b₂c₁	60	13	1
M9	a₃b₃c₂	60	18	2

组别 Group	处理组合 Treatment combination	a：种植密度 Planting density/（kg·m^-3）	b：养殖密度 Breeding density/（kg·m^-3）	c：投喂频率/（次·d^-1） Feeding frequency/（times·d^-1）
M1	a₁b₁c₁	32	8	1
M2	a₁b₂c₂	32	13	2
M3	a₁b₃c₃	32	18	3
M4	a₂b₁c₂	46	8	2
M5	a₂b₂c₃	46	13	3
M6	a₂b₃c₁	46	18	1
M7	a₃b₁c₃	60	8	3
M8	a₃b₂c₁	60	13	1
M9	a₃b₃c₂	60	18	2

组别 Group	初始体质量 Initial weight/g	终末体质量 Terminal weight/g	增重量 Increase weight/g	增重率Weight gain rate/%	特定生长率Specific growth rate/（%·d^-1）	饲料系数Feed conversion ratio	成活率Survival rate/%
M1	313.46±12.35 a	554.66±25.47 cd	241.20±22.14 cd	76.95±11.23 cd	1.43±0.03 cd	1.56±0.09b	98 a
M2	317.14±15.66 a	525.13±36.12 d	207.99±12.83 d	65.58±8.17 d	1.25±0.18 e	1.83±0.04 a	98 a
M3	315.73±15.12 a	534.62±38.27 d	218.89±19.28 d	69.33± 7.28 d	1.33±0.04 de	1.73±0.13 a	100 a
M4	315.47±12.02 a	632.23±32.45 b	316.76±15.38 b	100.41±9.26 b	1.75±0.15 b	1.20±0.08 cd	99 a
M5	318.11±13.47 a	655.59±31.22 a	337.48±27.13 a	106.09±16.28 a	1.83±0.09 a	1.13±0.07 cd	100 a
M6	319.06±12.88 a	592.44±25.31 bc	273.38±23.17 bc	85.68±10.05 bc	1.53±0.02 bc	1.40±0.13 bc	100 a
M7	313.23±15.46 a	558.18±24.19 cd	244.95±18.92 cd	78.20±12.82 cd	1.43±0.03 cd	1.53±0.07 b	98 a
M8	316.53±13.80 a	639.12±31.25 b	322.59±16.18 b	101.91±10.05 b	1.75±0.05 b	1.18±0.12 cd	100 a
M9	315.44±12.44 a	596.76±26.11 bc	281.32±21.15 bc	89.18±8.19 bc	1.60±0.04 bc	1.35±0.17 bc	100 a

组别 Group	初始体质量 Initial weight/g	终末体质量 Terminal weight/g	增重量 Increase weight/g	增重率Weight gain rate/%	特定生长率Specific growth rate/（%·d^-1）	饲料系数Feed conversion ratio	成活率Survival rate/%
M1	313.46±12.35 a	554.66±25.47 cd	241.20±22.14 cd	76.95±11.23 cd	1.43±0.03 cd	1.56±0.09b	98 a
M2	317.14±15.66 a	525.13±36.12 d	207.99±12.83 d	65.58±8.17 d	1.25±0.18 e	1.83±0.04 a	98 a
M3	315.73±15.12 a	534.62±38.27 d	218.89±19.28 d	69.33± 7.28 d	1.33±0.04 de	1.73±0.13 a	100 a
M4	315.47±12.02 a	632.23±32.45 b	316.76±15.38 b	100.41±9.26 b	1.75±0.15 b	1.20±0.08 cd	99 a
M5	318.11±13.47 a	655.59±31.22 a	337.48±27.13 a	106.09±16.28 a	1.83±0.09 a	1.13±0.07 cd	100 a
M6	319.06±12.88 a	592.44±25.31 bc	273.38±23.17 bc	85.68±10.05 bc	1.53±0.02 bc	1.40±0.13 bc	100 a
M7	313.23±15.46 a	558.18±24.19 cd	244.95±18.92 cd	78.20±12.82 cd	1.43±0.03 cd	1.53±0.07 b	98 a
M8	316.53±13.80 a	639.12±31.25 b	322.59±16.18 b	101.91±10.05 b	1.75±0.05 b	1.18±0.12 cd	100 a
M9	315.44±12.44 a	596.76±26.11 bc	281.32±21.15 bc	89.18±8.19 bc	1.60±0.04 bc	1.35±0.17 bc	100 a

指标Index	项目Item	因素Factor
指标Index	项目Item	a：种植密度 Planting density	b：养殖密度 Breeding density	c：投喂频率 Feeding frequency
增重量 Increase weight/g	K₁	222.693	267.637	267.107
	K₂	309.207	289.353	268.690
	K₃	298.953	257.863	279.057
	最佳水平Optimal level	a₂	b₂	c₃
	R	86.514	31.490	11.950
	水平数量 Horizontal quantity	3	3	3
	每水平重复数 Number of repetitions per level	3.0	3.0	3.0
	P值 P value	0.035	0.567	0.042
增重率 Weight gain rate/%	K₁	70.620	85.186	84.540
	K₂	97.394	91.196	85.058
	K₃	89.766	81.398	88.182
	最佳水平Optimal level	a₂	b₂	c₃
	R	26.774	9.798	3.642
	水平数量 Horizontal quantity	3	3	3
	每水平重复数 Number of repetitions per level	3.0	3.0	3.0
	P值 P value	0.033	0.055	0.641
特定生长率 Specific growth rate/（%·d^-1）	K₁	1.333	1.533	1.525
	K₂	1.700	1.608	1.533
	K₃	1.592	1.483	1.567
	最佳水平Optimal level	a₂	b₂	c₃
	R	0.367	0.125	0.042
	水平数量 Horizontal quantity	3	3	3
	每水平重复数 Number of repetitions per level	3.0	3.0	3.0
	P值 P value	0.003	0.184	0.723

鱼菜共生系统中种养密度和投喂频率对大口黑鲈生长及水质的影响

Effect of Aquapnics Cultrue Mode on Growth of Micropterus salmoides and Water Quality

RichHTML

PDF

可视化

摘要/Abstract

引用本文

使用本文

图/表 12

参考文献 31

相关文章 15

编辑推荐

Metrics

组别 Group	水分 Moisture	灰分 Ash	粗蛋白 Crude protein	粗脂肪 Crude fat
M1	71.89±11.22 a	1.35±0.03 bc	16.28±5.89 bc	1.73±0.11 b
M2	71.67±10.69 a	1.48±0.05 b	18.05±3.32 a	1.73±0.32 b
M3	70.35±11.98 a	1.45±0.09 b	18.71±2.80 a	2.27±0.36 a
M4	72.55±9.88 a	1.23±0.04 cd	17.08±6.29 b	1.85±0.22 b
M5	71.22±14.27 a	1.24±0.08 cd	18.67±3.43 a	2.35±0.31 a
M6	72.68±12.11 a	0.83±0.05 d	16.73±5.26 bc	1.58±0.88 bc
M7	70.39±13.38 a	1.37±0.05 bc	18.32±1.45 a	2.41±0.27 a
M8	71.72±10.82 a	1.53±0.04 a	16.54±3.37 bc	1.65±0.55 bc
M9	71.30±11.59 a	1.32±0.06 bc	18.45±3.39 a	1.70±0.46 b

组别 Group	水温 Water temperature/℃	溶解氧 Dissolved oxygen/（mg·L^-1）	pH	电导率 EC/（mS·cm^-1）
M1	25	7.32	7.13	1.24
M2	26	7.51	7.25	1.24
M3	26	7.45	7.46	1.23
M4	25	7.24	7.32	1.23
M5	25	7.29	7.35	1.24
M6	26	7.23	7.41	1.23
M7	25	7.22	7.38	1.24
M8	26	7.28	7.29	1.23
M9	25	7.31	7.23	1.22

组别 Group	采样时间 Sampling time/d
组别 Group	1	7	13	19	25	31	37	43	49	55	60
M1	0.192±0.022 b	3.597±0.154 b	1.556±0.103 bc	1.817±0.168 b	2.497±0.334 bc	1.822±0.177 a	0.856±0.033 a	0.637±0.087 b	0.635±0.081 b	0.656±0.087 b	0.641±0.133 bc
M2	0.207±0.055 a	4.145±0.764 a	1.741±0.085 a	1.820±0.064 b	2.746±0.096 a	1.637±0.211 bc	0.829±0.150 a	0.736±0.055 a	0.757±0.020 a	0.849±0.047 a	0.872±0.091 b
M3	0.255±0.012 a	3.834±0.349 b	1.625±0.172 b	1.624±0.199 cd	2.717±0.165 a	1.737±0.072 b	0.855±0.390 a	0.775±0.181 a	0.641±0.138 b	0.831±0.047 a	0.921±0.034 a
M4	0.248±0.032 a	3.725±0.336 b	1.655±0.172 b	1.747±0.073 bc	2.432±0.461 bc	1.595±0.167 cd	0.588±0.049 bc	0.491±0.036 cd	0.483±0.038 cd	0.487±0.03607 cd	0.431± 0.011 d
M5	0.253±0.022 a	3.533±0.083 b	1.623±0.184 b	1.859±0.054 b	2.475±0.062 bc	1.561±0.075 cd	0.648±0.085 b	0.482±0.011 cd	0.458±0.086 cd	0.472±0.048 cd	0.424±0.025 d
M6	0.187±0.012 b	3.654±0.193 b	1.627±0.114 b	1.834±0.037 b	2.242±0.091 d	1.586±0.108 cd	0.601±0.127 b	0.503±0.126 bc	0.516±0.144 bc	0.526±0.178 bc	0.473±0.011 d
M7	0.221±0.022 a	3.726±0.098 b	1.684±0.093 b	1.827±0.081 b	2.486±0.174 bc	1.637±0.049 bc	0.652±0.070 b	0.531±0.095 bc	0.542±0.070 bc	0.532±0.071 bc	0.523±0.08 cd
M8	0.215±0.033 a	3.853±0.289 b	1.711±0.115 a	1.913±0.047 a	2.513±0.327 b	1.623±0.156 bc	0.673±0.101 b	0.528±0.063 bc	0.544±0.070 bc	0.546±0.068 bc	0.557±0.060 cd
M9	0.225±0.029 a	3.612±0.456 b	1.706±0.129 a	1.852±0.063 b	2.511±0.324 b	1.593±0.082 cd	0.657±0.083 b	0.516±0.088 bc	0.529±0.073 bc	0.512±0.072 bc	0.528±0.032 cd

组别 Group	采样时间 Sampling time/d
组别 Group	1	7	13	19	25	31	37	43	49	55	60
M1	0.001 6±0.000 5 a	1.573 5±0.325 3 b	1.927 1±0.197 6 a	1.326 8±0.045 4 b	0.533 4±0.115 1 a	0.102 7±0.018 9 a	0.015 8±0.006 5 b	0.011 9±0.008 5 a	0.091 3±0.015 0 a	0.091 5±0.019 5 a	0.008 4±0.000 2 b
M2	0.001 4±0.000 2 bc	1.624 9±0.207 1 a	1.881 4±0.053 8 b	1.396 5±0.089 3 b	0.489 7±0.084 8 b	0.095 3±0.023 6 b	0.020 3±0.008 4 a	0.016 2±0.006 5 a	0.015 2±0.003 2 b	0.010 9±0.001 5 b	0.009 4±0.000 4 a
M3	0.001 5±0.000 7 b	1.654 5±0.204 2 a	1.907 7±0.039 1 a	1.411 3±0.098 0 a	0.521 5±0.045 9 a	0.132 9±0.017 1 a	0.021 3±0.009 4 a	0.018 2±0.005 7 a	0.017 9±0.003 3 b	0.012 6±0.000 8 b	0.009 3±0.000 3 a
M4	0.001 5±0.000 8 b	1.459 7±0.107 6 bc	1.621 3±0.099 8 cd	1.123 8±0.115 4 cd	0.343 7±0.095 4 bc	0.084 4±0.011 2 bc	0.013 0±0.004 8 b	0.007 7±0.002 5 b	0.005 7±0.001 5 cd	0.005 5±0.001 1 bc	0.005 2±0.000 3 bc
M5	0.0015±0.001 1 b	1.427 1±0.079 6 bc	1.781 1±0.211 3 bc	0.907 2±0.051 8 d	0.313 6±0.088 0 bc	0.075 1±0.011 6 cd	0.005 4±0.001 3 bcd	0.005 7±0.001 4 cd	0.005 6±0.001 6 cd	0.005 4±0.000 4 bc	0.005 3±0.000 2 bc
M6	0.001 6±0.000 4 a	1.461 9±0.231 8 bc	1.795 3±0.223 9 bc	1.111 0±0.175 0 cd	0.415 8±0.020 4 b	0.079 8±0.010 3 cd	0.008 8±0.001 5 bc	0.006 5±0.001 2 bc	0.005 9±0.001 8 cd	0.005 1±0.000 2 bc	0.005 2±0.000 3 bc
M7	0.001 5±0.000 8 b	1.494 2±0.157 1 bc	1.827 9±0.055 8 b	1.121 8±0.009 1 cd	0.403 2±0.015 4 b	0.093 3±0.027 1 b	0.007 4±0.001 0 cd	0.006 2±0.001 5 bc	0.006 4±0.001 6 bc	0.005 3±0.000 6 bc	0.005 0±0.000 2 bc
M8	0.001 3±0.000 6 cd	1.435 1±0.073 7 bc	1.794 2±0.037 9 bc	1.228 0±0.167 4 bc	0.382 2±0.048 9 bc	0.126 9±0.019 5 a	0.007 6±0.000 7 cd	0.007 5±0.000 7 b	0.006 2±0.001 0 bc	0.005 6±0.000 9 bc	0.005 1±0.000 1 bc
M9	0.001 3±0.000 7 cd	1.462 8±0.046 9 bc	1.852 6±0.069 4 b	0.973 1±0.177 9 d	0.375 8±0.054 8 bc	0.083 0±0.024 3 bc	0.006 4±0.001 1 d	0.006 2±0.000 8 bc	0.005 8±0.000 4 cd	0.005 2±0.000 6 bc	0.005 1±0.000 3 bc

组别 Group	采样时间 Sampling time/d
组别 Group	1	7	13	19	25	31	37	43	49	55	60
M1	1.212±0.088 a	8.718±1.864 b	8.319±1.932 b	7.646±0.613 b	7.793±1.605 b	7.733±1.040 b	6.451±1.310 b	6.727±1.219 b	6.597±1.279 b	6.139±1.260 b	6.091±2.411 b
M2	1.093±0.613 bc	9.242±0.207 a	9.075±0.054 a	8.454±0.090 a	8.242±0.085 a	8.444±0.024 a	7.165±0.008 a	7.268±0.007 a	7.500±0.003 a	7.163±0.002 a	7.155±0.000 a
M3	1.141±0.020 b	8.639±1.706 b	7.463±0.976 bc	7.430±1.492 b	6.483±0.930 bc	6.861±0.980 bc	6.141±1.642 b	6.458±1.425 b	7.128±1.543 a	7.639±1.042 a	7.834±2.301 a
M4	1.126±0.017 b	8.540±1.072 b	7.924±0.960 bc	6.868±1.583 bc	5.894±0.742 cd	5.765±1.074 cd	4.877±1.428 cd	4.726±1.422 cd	4.813±0.950 cd	4.637±0.798 cd	4.522±1.281 cd
M5	1.058±0.039 bc	8.338±1.102 b	7.853±1.614 bc	6.452±1.659 bc	5.247±1.14 cd	5.405±0.778 cd	4.535±0.522 cd	4.516±1.115 cd	4.429±1.146 cd	4.324±0.828 cd	4.273±1.321 cd
M6	1.224±0.085 a	8.843±1.664 b	8.236±0.842 b	7.425±0.905 b	6.680±1.235 bc	6.209±1.280 bc	5.557±1.354 bc	5.499±2.102 bc	5.856±1.694 bc	5.720±1.434 bc	5.672±1.723 bc
M7	1.036±0.027 bc	8.424±1.164 b	8.916±1.190 b	8.746±1.543 a	8.146±1.503 a	6.575±1.076 bc	6.280±0.882 b	6.455±0.374 b	6.262±1.116 b	6.314±0.893 b	6.261±2.582 b
M8	1.153±0.029 b	8.744±0.841 b	8.621±1.308 b	8.378±0.911 a	8.519±0.858 a	7.654±0.813 b	7.441±1.015 a	7.534±1.317 a	7.283±0.959 a	7.217±1.260 a	7.332±2.433 a
M9	1.131±0.011 b	8.634±1.525 b	8.742±0.882 b	8.624±0.904 a	8.614±1.575 a	8.298±1.323 a	7.141±1.626 a	7.217±1.744 a	7.189±1.563 a	6.888±1.740 b	7.154±2.492 a

组别 Group	采样时间 Sampling time/d
组别 Group	1	7	13	19	25	31	37	43	49	55	60
M1	0.141±0.027 bc	0.390±0.045 b	0.711±0.101 b	0.659±0.098 b	0.438±0.104 b	0.591±0.138 b	0.622±0.106 a	0.681±0.057 b	0.753±0.112 b	0.716±0.109 b	0.724±0.120 b
M2	0.156±0.026 b	0.436±0.129 a	0.788±0.071 b	0.648±0.134 b	0.434±0.110 b	0.622±0.154 a	0.656±0.085 a	0.713±0.136 a	0.774±0.103 b	0.763±0.093 b	0.783±0.151 b
M3	0.144±0.037 bc	0.418±0.062 a	0.814±0.076 a	0.637±0.156 b	0.488±0.081 b	0.686±0.154 a	0.639±0.054 a	0.707±0.029 a	0.857±0.098 a	0.912±0.069 a	0.957±0.122 a
M4	0.168±0.029 a	0.375±0.144 b	0.747±0.216 b	0.657±0.232 b	0.516±0.090 a	0.644±0.101 a	0.542±0.080 b	0.712±0.142 a	0.747±0.155 b	0.674±0.188 bc	0.582±0.180 cd
M5	0.155±0.053 b	0.372±0.110 b	0.751±0.108 b	0.662±0.141 b	0.415±0.082 b	0.585±0.147 b	0.561±0.067 b	0.614±0.158 b	0.633±0.048 bc	0.631±0.064 bc	0.623±0.211 bc
M6	0.143±0.053 bc	0.387±0.182 b	0.764±0.052 b	0.686±0.210 b	0.485±0.082 b	0.591±0.088 b	0.561±0.081 b	0.603±0.129 b	0.657±0.106 bc	0.685±0.144 bc	0.636±0.251 bc
M7	0.146±0.051 bc	0.394±0.055 b	0.776±0.117 b	0.698±0.157 b	0.477±0.058 b	0.614±0.117 a	0.589±0.180 b	0.749±0.075 a	0.696±0.081 bc	0.685±0.123 bc	0.432±0.030 d
M8	0.145±0.052 bc	0.370±0.129 b	0.794±0.225 b	0.713±0.197 a	0.485±0.137 b	0.664±0.164 a	0.617±0.144 a	0.692±0.111 b	0.736±0.143 b	0.674±0.124 bc	0.485±0.051 d
M9	0.142±0.020 bc	0.390±0.038 b	0.764±0.162 b	0.690±0.174 b	0.465±0.096 b	0.659±0.120 a	0.609±0.133 a	0.644±0.157 b	0.624±0.130 bc	0.678±0.127 bc	0.447±0.021 d

[1]	姚佳琦, 杨春彦, 杨云凤, 白皓, 江勇, 常国斌, 陈国宏, 王志秀. 肌肉与脂肪组织互作调节肌内脂肪沉积的研究进展[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2025, 27(9): 21-34.
[2]	刘之恩, 何勇, 王志成, 詹逍康, 王廷宝, 刘耀威, 田志宏. 水稻生长调节因子GRF基因家族的鉴定及生物信息学分析[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2025, 27(8): 18-27.
[3]	黄娟娟, 张志强, 毛娟, 马宗桓, 陈佰鸿. 不同叶面肥对‘黑比诺’葡萄生长发育和果实品质的影响[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2025, 27(6): 205-217.
[4]	吴小丹, 高丽, 巩天耕, 孔祥凤, 姜雨舟, 贾桂霞. 微生物菌肥和腐植酸复合肥对百合生长和光合特性的影响[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2025, 27(4): 221-229.
[5]	王宁宁, 罗雪梅, 陈明媛, 郭睿, 刘建国. 外源褪黑素对盐旱复合胁迫下油莎豆种子萌发和幼苗生长的影响[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2025, 27(2): 51-61.
[6]	周文豪, 张玉涵, 孟德龙, 梁慧, 张元培, 杨雅麟, 张震, 药园园, 冉超, 周志刚. 贝莱斯芽孢杆菌在养殖业中的应用研究进展[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2025, 27(11): 1-7.
[7]	金玉倩, 傅子恒, 高小语, 李为民. 枣植原体分泌蛋白ncSP35抑制超敏反应及植物生长发育[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2025, 27(11): 164-173.
[8]	闫芸芸, 汪福保, 董浚键, 张赫桐, 高风英, 张媛, 叶星, 孙成飞, 吴成宾. 配合饲料替代活饵对翘嘴鳜生长性能、消化功能及抗氧化能力的影响[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2025, 27(11): 32-42.
[9]	杨飞, 冯仲科, 周杨杨, 程文生, 王智超. 适于GlobalAllomeTree国际数据平台的标准化中国主要树种树高-胸径方程研建[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2024, 26(9): 62-71.
[10]	吴梅, 张金珠, 王振华, 刘健, 温越, 李宣志. 水气互作对膜下滴灌玉米生理生长及产量的影响[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2024, 26(8): 189-200.
[11]	王翻兄, 徐英, 沙玉柱, 邵鹏阳, 谢转回, 李文浩, 王继卿, 李少斌, 陈小伟, 杨文鑫, 刘秀. 不同年龄藏绵羊肌肉脂肪酸特征分析[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2024, 26(8): 74-83.
[12]	马力, 曹婷婷, 范又维, 任志雨, 刘春, 袁素霞. 不同生根试剂对微型盆栽月季扦插生根的影响[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2024, 26(7): 50-60.
[13]	付彦博, 冷冰冰, 扁青永, 董志多, 刘国宏, 李海峰, 温云梦, 郭文博, 张万旭. 生物炭和油菜幼苗对土壤重金属镉污染的钝化效应[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2024, 26(6): 183-190.
[14]	彭守华, 许铭铭, 尉继强, 梁丽君, 叶全, 迟晓元, 张少峰, 董向丽. 生物菌肥FBR1不同施用方式对花生生长发育及产量的影响[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2024, 26(6): 200-205.
[15]	蒋飞, 施永海, 徐嘉波, 严银龙, 刘永士, 袁新程. 2种饲料投喂下美洲鲥幼鱼肌肉营养成分分析及评价[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2024, 26(5): 223-233.